What Happened to Cale Makar? A Detailed Look at the Hockey Star’s Recent Struggles and Success

Cale Makar, one of the most talented defensemen in the National Hockey League (NHL), has recently faced a mix of challenges and triumphs. Makar’s journey has been eventful, from battling illness during international tournaments to addressing past controversies. This report breaks down his recent health issues, on-ice performances, and the lingering questions about his involvement in a 2018 incident.

Recent Illness and Missed Games

Health Scare at the Four Nations Face-Off

In February 2025, Cale Makar was set to represent Team Canada in the Four Nations Face-Off, a prestigious hockey tournament. However, he fell ill just before a crucial game against Team USA. According to ESPN, Makar skipped practice on February 14 due to the illness but participated in a morning skate the next day. Team Canada’s coach, Jon Cooper, called him a “game-time decision” but emphasized that they would not risk his health. Despite showing improvement, Makar was ruled out an hour before the game. Thomas Harley, a Dallas Stars defenseman, replaced him temporarily.

Impact on Team Canada

Makar’s absence was a blow to Canada’s defense. Earlier in the tournament, Shea Theodore (another key defenseman) suffered an upper-body injury, leaving the team short-handed. Makar had played a team-high 28 minutes in their opening game against Sweden, showcasing his importance. His illness forced Canada to rely on fewer players, highlighting his irreplaceable role.

The 2018 Incident: Lingering Questions

Allegations and Public Response

In 2018, Makar was part of Canada’s World Junior team, which faced allegations of misconduct. While Makar was not directly accused, his name surfaced in discussions. A Reddit thread revealed fans questioning his involvement. Makar repeatedly denied participation, stating, “I can’t stress enough that I wasn’t part of that”. Despite this, Hockey Canada initially banned all 2018 team members from international events, though rumors suggest Makar’s ban might be lifted sooner.

Implications for His Career

The controversy cast a shadow over Makar’s reputation. Fans debated whether he deserved punishment for merely being part of the team. His clean record and consistent denials helped him avoid major backlash, but the incident remains a sensitive topic.

Injury History and Recovery

Chronic Lower-Body Issues

Makar has struggled with injuries throughout his career. In December 2024, he missed games due to a lower-body injury, sparking concerns about his durability. A Reddit post noted he has only played over 60 games in a season once, raising questions about his long-term fitness. Fans speculated that rushing back from injuries worsened his condition.

Recent Setbacks

During the 2024-25 NHL season, Makar’s turnovers and defensive errors drew criticism. A highlighted mistake against the New York Islanders led to a shorthanded goal, with fans joking, “Cale Makar transforming into Darnell Nurse”. Despite these blunders, supporters defended him, noting that even elite players make mistakes.

Performance Highlights and Awards

Norris Trophy Dominance

Makar won the Norris Trophy (awarded to the NHL’s best defenseman) in 2022. His offensive skills set him apart—he scored 22 goals and 63 points in 57 games during the 2024-25 season, leading all defensemen.

Clutch Plays and Leadership

In January 2025, Makar scored his first goal as a member of the Colorado Avalanche after a trade, assisted by Martin Necas. The play showcased his sharp shooting and teamwork[^5]. Fans praised his adaptability and immediate impact.

The Trade to Colorado Avalanche

Adjusting to a New Team

After joining the Avalanche, Makar initially struggled to score but gradually found his rhythm. His partnership with Devon Toews (his defensive teammate) stabilized Colorado’s backline. A Reddit user joked, “Avs won the trade” after his first goal, though critics argued it was too early to judge.

Fan Reactions

Supporters expressed mixed feelings. Some worried about his consistency, while others celebrated his potential. One fan noted, “He’s on thin ice tbh, might just get cut if he doesn’t improve”, reflecting the pressure on Makar to perform.

Legacy and Future Outlook

Role in Team Canada’s Olympic Hopes

Makar’s health will be critical for the 2026 Winter Olympics. If Hockey Canada maintains its ban on 2018 World Junior players, his absence could weaken the team. However, insiders predict exemptions for star players like Makar.

Long-Term Career Prospects

At 26, Makar is in his prime. His blend of speed, scoring, and defensive IQ makes him a franchise player. However, injuries and workload management will determine his longevity. As one analyst noted, “He’s the future of hockey defense—if he stays healthy”.

Summary of Key Events

Event	Date	Details	Source
Illness before USA-Canada game	February 2025	Missed game due to illness; replaced by Thomas Harley	Sportsnet
2018 World Junior controversy	2018	Denied involvement in alleged incident; ban from Hockey Canada	Reddit
Lower-body injury	December 2024	Missed games; history of recurring injuries	Reddit
Trade to Avalanche	January 2025	Scored first goal with Colorado; mixed fan reactions	Reddit

This report simplifies complex hockey terms and events for younger readers while maintaining factual accuracy. Clickable links direct readers to original sources for further exploration.